Skip Navigation LinksCommentaries

RSS RSS

WDI presents commentaries to foster conversations about social and ethical issues.


Go Back

A new New Deal

Ed Murphy“Only the hand that erases can write the true thing”

Meister Eckhart

My head hurts when I realize how life has changed since I left high school. In June of 1963, gas sold for 29 cents a gallon. American-made cars filled the roads. President Kennedy was alive. Segregation kept African-Americans from voting.  I knew Vietnam was somewhere in Asia.  

War taught me where and now we outsource manufacturing jobs to a country I first fought and then learned to love. We fill foreign cars with $3 gasoline. Barack Obama is President. We use cell phones and bury our youth killed in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Still values endure. I share family news through e mail; Skype with our son in Africa and meet friends on Facebook. I grew up in what seemed like a small town on rural Staten Island, where fathers went into “the city” to work. Today I feed birds in my upstate back yard and watch wild turkeys walk out of the woods. I commute with men and women to the State Capital for work. Geography and technology have brought dramatic changes. Consciousness evolves more slowly.  The question is which values have we kept through all these changes?

Our organization and definition of family has evolved but I believe it remains strong.  We are more open to alternative, discussing the challenges of marriage and gender roles. We no longer accept that children should be seen not heard. Thanksgiving still brings us home. Births and deaths draw the same emotions and parents still show up for school plays, Little League and recitals.

Despite globalization, frustration with our government and our conflicting perspectives we argue about America because patriotism still matters, “My country right or wrong” is no longer our guide, however. More say “where she is right, let’s keep her right and where she is wrong let’s make her right.”

Community is an essential value, only the form has changed. We meet in more locations, with greater ethnic diversity than our parents, rely on newer technologies to communicate and have global neighbors.  

Employment still defines us. WDI has been conducting focus groups and surveys of workers; those who have lost their jobs and others who live in fear. Their stories are not that different from earlier generations. Without work they feel small and abandoned.

I remember hearing stories from the great Depression of men and women who worked for little or no money, sometimes only to maintain their dignity.  I played in parks developed through the WPA, learned in libraries built through public employment programs and played on ball fields created by volunteers. Pride is the motivating force that has built our nation, brought refugees and immigrants out of poverty and sustained our communities. “Work is love made visible” as Kahlil Gibran wrote years ago.

It is time for a new New Deal. National security must be redefined beyond war. Our nation will only be secure when all Americans have economic security and our international neighbors do too.  None of us want handouts, just the right to earn their way, strengthen our communities and support their families. We demand an opportunity to work.  The billions made through hedge funds could strengthen healthcare, pay salaries of teachers, employ our dislocated workers, rebuild the infrastructure of our tired cities and grow new and green industries.

In one of our focus groups we held a drawing for a gift certificate. An unemployed man who won tried to give it to a woman who was clearly having a harder time. She refused, saying he won and she had not earned it. Was this foolish pride or a well founded sense of self worth? I don’t know.  I do know that our greatest asset for rebuilding New York and this country is the skills and strength of our own people.

Much has changed in my lifetime but essentials remain. The combined effort of millions pulled us out of one depression, led by a government that respected its people, recognized there is dignity in work and marshaled American citizens’ pride and commitment to family, community and nation. Instead of learning the lesson of cheap labor from China we would better pay attention to their word for crisis and understand it also means opportunity.

In this economic crisis we would be smarter to bail out the people than the banks. Let’s apply Meister Eckhart’s principle; erase our decades of distrust in government led solutions and write the true thing. We need a new New Deal led by a government that puts our people back to work.

Together we can rebuild the infrastructure of our communities, install free high speed internet that will encourage a diversified economy. President Eisenhower built our interstate highway system using the logic of national defense, stimulating commerce at the same time. We need to revitalize our communities, complex transportation systems and add a stronger high speed internet communications highway.  

Our people are ready and waiting for government to respond.

  • Facebook
  • DZone It!
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Del.icio.us
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Blinklist
  • Furl it!

Comments  4

  • Greg 5/26/2010 12:00:00 AM

    Ed truly has hit on a defining issue in regards to facing who we are as a country. We hear from some quarters that "we must take our country back". Should we not want our country to move forward instead? We can certainly learn from the past and reach back for lessons that have worked, such as the New Deal. For those interested, check out the oral history done by Studs Terkel: Working. The way working people got out of the Great Depression was to help each other and pull together. The same will be true of the Great Recession. It will be the basic goodness, the diversity, and the strength of people and community that will do it.
  • Paul 5/28/2010 12:00:00 AM

    For most of my adult life I've felt that the absence of a dignified job is at the root of so many problems in America and around the world; but especially in America where we place such a high value on our working lives. With all of the political rhetoric about things that are troubling about this country, if we could channel our resources and energy (and rhetoric) into jobs and preparing people for jobs, this would go a long way toward solving many social ills.  I also think that our educational institutions need to spend more time thinking about the skills that we need today, and be a bit more futuristic in their thinking about tomorrow (they really need to expand their thinking about this).  There just seems to be a big disconnect between what goes on in the classroom and what the skill needs are and might be. 
  • Devorah Hill 5/30/2010 12:00:00 AM

    As I  gaze into the future I also wonder what in fact lies ahead. How do we have a substantive conversation about defining community? What have we learn from the past and how do we apply those lesson concretely to the present and the future? The primary objective seems to me to work at removing the fear of "otherness" in our conversation about community. Creating a safe place to participate in the "American experience" on multiple levels.

    WDI is on the cutting edge of creating that safe place for workers. In those focus groups I should think people feel safe enough to speak with out fear of judgment about their apprehensions. The development of that safe space enables people to move beyond their  vulnerability and embrace their individual and collective strength, develop a respect for difference while making an effort to identify common objectives.

    That which you put forward here harkens to Dr. King's question, "Where do we go from here, Chaos or Community?" You are quite right, it will take the collective effort of millions to pull ourselves back from our national financial fragility. It will take that same multitude to pull us back from the brink of humanitarian bankruptcy. "Work is love made visible" when we understand that we are our brothers' and sisters' keeper. That if one worker is abused all workers are vulnerable. China's "affordable labor" holds out the foreshadowing of how a sense of helplessness can lead to disfunction and chaos. Seemingly normal Chinese citizens have exhibited horrific violence not against the machinery the holds their life in abeyance but against the most vulnerable amongst them

    The similarities between the time of the New Deal and now are not lost on those who pay close attention to history. We need pause and ask,"What was missed then that we can not afford to miss now?" I would say it is inclusiveness. The New Deal provided the foundation for "America" embracing the idea of a national living standard. But let us not forget that domestic and many agricultural laborers were left completely out of the discourse. Eisenhower built an infrastructure that empowered many but absolutely did not consider all. The interstate highway system displaced whole communities through eminent domain. It bifurcated  municipalities in ways that we have still not recuperated from. An experience that, to this day, has a socioeconomic imprint on many cities including Troy. This same infrastructure, in combination with its socio-geographic bifurcation, privatized mobility, decimated the support for mass transit and was a contributing factor in the development of sub-urban sprawl.

    The "distrust of government" is in fact our distrust of ourselves. The "government" is not some external thing. We are the government. Our's is  a government by and for the people. It is not a fast food, instant gratification, social system. Our "government" entails intense and protracted participation. In order to trust  "our government," that is trust  our national selves, we need to be involved in an earnest public dialogue a "truth and reconciliation," if you will. We need to develop our inter-personal skills on a national level so that we can start "speaking with"  and actively "listening to" each other. Let our questioning be in the service of clarity not for the gratification of intellectual conquest. Through an earnest effort to use non-violent communication we can build a common language of patriotism as the "national work." Then we can manifest  Kahlil Gibran's thesis of  “Work is love made visible."

    My hope is that  the safe space made possible by WDI will be the germinating soil that brings theory into practice.
  • zack@12 3/20/2012 12:00:00 AM

    I have days I wish I never went to graduate school. On the other days, I wish I could go and get a PhD (would help me immensely from a professional standpoint), but don't want to take on more loan debt. I can't start up a 401K yet, or buy a house, or build a savings, because my debt load is too high.

    Stadium seats

    I'm even at the point of saying no to having children. Can I afford the extra expense? Can I save for their college costs 20 years from now? Do I want them going through what I am going through? No way.

Post a comment!
  1. Formatting options
       
     
     
     
     
       

  2. * Enter the text shown:  

Subscriptions Calendar Resources Commentaries Twitter Subscriptions Facebook Commentaries Subscriptions Calendar Resources Commentaries Twitter Facebook Subscriptions You Tube